Once upon a time, many scientists believed that because endurance athletes consumed and used a lot more oxygen than the average couch potato, they could benefit from an increased intake of antioxidants. The idea was that antioxidant supplements might help prevent an increase in free radical damage caused by all that oxygen flooding through the muscles, which in turn could help to protect muscle cells from tissue breakdown, thereby reducing post-exercise muscle soreness and speeding recovery. However, there’s a big fly in the antioxidant supplement ointment; while antioxidant supplements do seem to offer some protection against muscle damage, there’s very little evidence that this translates into improved endurance performance (see this article for more information on the link between antioxidants and performance).
The link between performance (at least in the shorter term) and antioxidant supplement intake is tenuous at best and maybe we should regard these supplements not as performance enhancers, but more as ‘protectors’ in the body. However, some scientists believe that antioxidant supplements fail to provide even these theoretical benefits – largely because one of the best ways to enhance your body’s antioxidant defences is to exercise more – something that athletes already do a lot of!
As an illustration of this point, an excellent study on the antioxidant statuses of professional cyclists by Spanish scientists makes for fascinating reading – and throws further doubt on the value of antioxidant supplementation(1). In this study, the researchers investigated how different phases of training affected oxidative stress and antioxidant defences in athletes.
Ten professional cyclists were enrolled, and then split into two groups of five: one group comprised of cyclists using a high-quality vitamin/antioxidant supplement while in the other, the cyclists took no supplements at all. Both groups then followed the same design of training programme, which consisted of periods of hard training, tapering periods and ‘recovery training’ periods. All the cyclists were assessed for the total antioxidant capacity of their diet (food plus any supplements) during the programme. In addition blood samples were taken to measure how effective the cyclists’ internal (ie what was happening with the cells of the body) antioxidant defence capacities were (plasma oxygen radical absorption capacity or ‘ORAC’ for short) and to measure how much oxidative damage (lipid peroxidation and DNA damage) the cyclists’ cells were experiencing.
The results showed that during the training programme, the cyclists who took vitamin/antioxidant supplements had a greater total antioxidant capacity as measured from blood sample (as might be expected). In theory, this should have meant these cyclists were better equipped to overcome and defend against antioxidant damage. However, the antioxidant defence capacities (ORAC) of both groups were NOT significantly different. And although the supplemented cyclists seemed to have slightly lower measures of lipid peroxidation at the start of the training period, by the end of the study, the measures of cell damage were pretty much identical in both groups. Yet another key finding was that in both groups, the cyclists’ overall ability to cope with oxidative stress improved equally throughout the training period, irrespective of supplementation.
What this study seems to suggest is that the body is more than capable of boosting its own internal antioxidant defences against oxidative stress, and that additional antioxidant supplements appear to have little or no effect. And in contrast to some previous studies(2-4), this one also found no reduction in cell damage as a result of supplementation. There’s also another issue to consider; recent evidence suggests that high doses of some antioxidant supplements could actually harm endurance performance because they impair the process of training adaptation by interfering with important free radical-dependent signalling processes in muscles (read more here)(5). In plain English, free radical generation during exercise seems to switch on genes involved with building endurance in muscle cells – too much free radical suppression with antioxidant supplements may therefore blunt your gains in aerobic fitness! In terms of practical recommendations, the best advice is as follows:
References
in Dietary basics, Endurance injuries and health, Nutrition for endurance athletes, Overuse injuries
Stress fractures are one of the most common and potentially serious overuse injuries reported in athletes, both elite and recreational. With this in mind, Andrew Hamilton looks at recent evidence linking stress fractures and nutritional status… MORE
in Dietary basics, Nutrition for endurance athletes
Optimum magnesium intake is vital for sport performance, yet many athletes still fail to fully appreciate its importance. In an update article, Peak Performance revisits this topic to see what the recent research says about magnesium for performance MORE
in Endurance health and lifestyle, Immunity, Recovery strategies, Training structure and planning
How should athletes prepare for a return to sport following coronavirus infection safely and effectively? Andrew Hamilton highlights some new research by UK scientists and provides practical guidelines MORE
in Hydration and fuelling on the move, Nutrition for endurance athletes, Other
Andrew Hamilton looks at optimum fueling strategies for a half marathon, and explains why one size doesn’t fit all MORE
in Hydration and fuelling on the move, Nutrition for endurance athletes, Supplements
Solid, gel or liquid? Peak Performance investigates how the choice of carbohydrate format affects performance... MORE
in Hydration and fuelling on the move, Nutrition for endurance athletes
A new breed of ‘gel-like’ carbohydrate drink claims to offer performance benefits for athletes. But are these claims supported by science? Andrew Hamilton investigates MORE
The latest triathlon research and best practice findings, covering improving technique, strength and conditioning, and endurance nutrition
The latest findings from running science with practical advice showing you how you can run further and faster whilst staying in peak health
